At Unlock Legal, our
seasoned team of professional license defense attorneys has over 20 years of experience, and we have become
uniquely skilled at walking our clients through every component of their legal
dilemma. In this two-part series, we will discuss Skelly hearings, starting
with what they are and what to expect.
What is a Skelly
A Skelly hearing gets its name from a California Supreme Court case
called Skelly v. State Personnel Board (1975) 15 Cal.3d 194. The Skelly court held that a civil service
or public sector employee has a property right to his job and could not be
deprived of it without due process.
Although called a
hearing, a Skelly hearing is better described as a pre-disciplinary due process
meeting. This procedural meeting ensures that when an employee is facing
disciplinary action, the accused employee is informed of the allegations, has
an opportunity to refute the allegations, and has an opportunity to mitigate
the allegations or rehabilitate their standing with their employer before any
actual disciplinary action. It is a preliminary meeting that must take place in
the case of an employee’s termination, demotion, suspension, reduction in pay,
or transfer with an accompanying loss in pay.
How does a Skelly hearing differ from a
The Skelly hearing
differs from a normal administrative hearing in that the process is usually simpler, faster, and less
expensive than a typical hearing. It’s a process where no witnesses testify,
and it typically requires very little paperwork and almost no discovery.
However, a Skelly hearing must meet the requirements as outlined in the Skelly
What are Skelly Rights?
Since the purpose of the
Skelly hearing is to allow an employee facing disciplinary action the
opportunity to state their case and share their side of the story, a set of
minimum requirements – called “rights” – must be met. They are as follows:
- The employee must receive notice of the proposed
discipline (a/k/a Notice of Adverse Action, or “Notice”);
- The Notice must identify the specific rule/policy
that has allegedly been violated by the employee;
- The Notice must allege factual basis for
violation (i.e., “cause for discipline”);
- The Notice must be served with all documents that
were relied upon by the official proposing the discipline;
- The Notice must provide deadline for any
- The Notice must include effective date of
What happens during the Skelly hearing?
During a Skelly hearing,
the accused employee and their legal representatives are present, along with
the official proposing the discipline or a representative from the official’s
office, someone from Human Resources or Employer Relations department, and the
Skelly Review Officer. The Skelly Review Officer usually reads the Notice to
those present and then allows the employee to respond to the allegations. After
the proceedings, the most common outcomes from a Skelly hearing include:
- Sustaining the allegations and level of
- Sustaining the allegations and reducing the level
- Requesting further investigation of the
allegations based upon information provided by the employee.
Have you received a
Notice of Intent to Terminate or Demote but don’t know what to do? Do not worry
– many people have been in your position. A Skelly hearing may seem daunting,
but it can be a relatively simple process that can help resolve your
disciplinary matter quickly. If you are facing disciplinary actions and have
been asked to appear at a Skelly hearing, contact
Unlock Legal today or give us a call at
your convenience at 949-268-2857. We routinely attend Skelly hearings in support
of our clients, and we are ready to represent you. In the meantime, if you’d
like to learn more about how you can prepare for your Skelly hearing, be sure
to read the second blog in this two-part series discussing what to do before
your Skelly hearing.